Photo
Popularity Rate down 0wattwatters who think this pulse is not really interesting Rate up 0wattwatters who think this pulse is interesting

Residential vs. Concentrated Solar Power

Taylen Peterson on May 22, 2009 | 1178 Views

Under the renewed guidance of an environmentally eager federal government, the race to transform the national energy grid from fossil fuels to renewable energy is picking up speed. Now, however, the debate has transformed from whether we should pursue alternative energy sources such as solar power to how we should get there.

In recent years the federal government has strongly supported utility scale solar power primarily in the form of large solar thermal plants, otherwise known as concentrated solar power (CSP). Yet the renewal and enhancement of residential solar tax credits and controversy surrounding remote desert CSP plants has heated up the debate as two which is better; large-scale solar power plants or small-scale residential solar power systems. Each has its pros and cons, revolving around a number of issues. Following are some of the major issues, and how they affect this ongoing debate:

Transmission - Proponents of residential, or distributed-generation, solar power argue that rooftop systems require few upgrades to the national electric grid, at least none that are not already necessary, while CSP plants require long and expensive transmission lines.

Sooner or Later - Proponents of CSP argue that if its renewable energy we want, the only way to get there in the time frame proposed by scientists and government is to adopt large scale power plants. Rooftop solar would just take too long. Residential solar enthusiasts argue that affordability, not simply ability, is the problem, and more aggressive policies such as feed-in tariffs (see Germany) would catalyze the residential and commercial PV industry.

Environment - A major reason for concern at the moment regarding CSP plants is their environmental impact. The reason these plants must be remote is that they require large swaths of land for acres of solar collectors, upsetting the local ecosystem. They also require large amounts of water for cooling in desert regions already short on water supply.

Cost - Perhaps affordability is the issue behind residential solar's slow spread, so why not let large solar firms and utilities pick up the slack with concentrated solar plants?

Space Saving - Some proponents have claimed that a single 100 square mile CSP plant in the desert southwest could power the entire United States. The popular counter to that is simply that there is already many times that amount of land available on rooftops throughout the country.

Energy Independence - A big plus for solar power of all types is its potential for reducing our dependency on foreign energy sources. While CSP takes big strides in that direction, it ignores the individual's energy independence. Rooftop solar has the potential to free families from utility bills altogether.

While individually described, all these issues are interrelated in their own way. Lower cost rooftop solar would facilitate that homeowner independence while naturally encouraging space and land savings by reducing the need for large-scale solar power plants. On the other hand, solar cannot get any cheaper than not having to pay for it at all (up front) and only solar power plants can effectively and speedily "clean" up the national grid while reducing costs and increasing energy security.

And the debate goes on.

| | | | |

Related pulses

Bloomenergy! A Clean, Reliable and Affordable fuel cell based Energy Server™ … Anywhere !

Jose Vaz Pinto on March 2, 2010 | 399 Views
The Energy Server™, unique on-site power generation system, utilizes an innovative fuel cell technology that leverages breakthrough advances in materials science. Bloom's Energy Server™ is a new class of ...

Saving money on lighting with power quality analyzer

Jerry Rodgers on March 1, 2010 | 163 Views
Lighting is a major element of operating costs for most facilities. Lighting costs involve both energy and maintenance. A company was considering replacing its existing lighting system and wanted to ...

Take care of your energy consumption, as it really pays !

Jose Vaz Pinto on February 17, 2010 | 412 Views
Use the more or less Smart Grid solutions already available near you ! It worths the small investment required and reduce energy invoices substantially ! Ecosystem: EcoFactor provides a residential energy management ...

Joule: The Unit of Measurement of electrical (really all) energy

Shrikant Dhekne on February 11, 2010 | 352 Views
********** Hi Jerry, This situation will lead nowhere, with diverse units remaining how cows. During transition years methods need to be evolved. Meters may simultaneously display energy in Joules, in addition ...

Measuring energy consumption

Jerry Rodgers on January 29, 2010 | 592 Views
The first step in reducing energy consumption is measuring how much you are using. Energy consumption consists of two primary components, power and demand. Power, measured in watts, indicates the ...

Solar Power in Public Transportation

Dean Dowd on January 26, 2010 | 889 Views
Solar-powered mass transit is key to U.S. energy sustainability. Did you know that one full city bus can keep 50 or more cars off the road? Or that a ...

Solar scooters in Rio de Janeiro

Yvonne Flavin on January 22, 2010 | 527 Views
We're hearing a lot of talk about electric cars but not so much about two-wheeled vehicles. Those of us who live and work in cities know that two-wheelers are ...

New MicroPhotoVoltaic Cells for Solar Concentrators

Jose Vaz Pinto on January 13, 2010 | 525 Views
"Sandia National Laboratories scientists have developed tiny glitter-sized photovoltaic cells that are expected to be less expensive and have greater efficiencies than current photovoltaic collectors pieced together with 6-inch-square solar ...

2010 - year of the electric car and a little food for thought

Philippa Martin-King on January 12, 2010 | 497 Views
The 2010 Detroit and LA motor shows have a concentration of electric cars. These are either hybrid, where they are differentiated into two categories of "mild" and "full" - with the ...

Times Square New Year's Eve Ball goes green

Yvonne Flavin on January 1, 2010 | 564 Views
And to continue our "pedal power" series, here's another one that caught my eye on the Engadget website the other day. I'm afraid I didn't actually watch ...

Fixing a vibrating transformer

Jerry Rodgers on January 1, 2010 | 557 Views
I ran into an interesting problem a few weeks ago so I am sharing in case it helps anyone else. A client in a large commercial building asked for help ...

SmartGrid - Compteurs intelligents

M. Denis Bloud on December 21, 2009 | 577 Views
La France va enfin installer, comme d'autres pays, des compteurs intelligents permettant une autorégulation du réseau par CPL. Ils s'agit des compteurs "Linky ". Le problème ...

looking for softcopy of P-IEC 60687 ed2.0 standard for 0.2S/0.5S Class electronic taroff meters

Gurmeet Anand on December 17, 2009 | 631 Views
IEC 687 standard has been replaced with a updated standard. Can somebdy give me a softcopy of this older standard? P-IEC 60687 ed2.0  regards  

Copenhagen's Christmas tree is lit by pedal-power

Yvonne Flavin on December 14, 2009 | 872 Views
Copenhagen has always been particularly bike-friendly - they were proposing free bikes to get around way before other cities - but this is taking things one step further. As Martin LaMonica said ...

When plugs start to talk... and help save energy

Yvonne Flavin on December 14, 2009 | 1130 Views
The stuff of science fiction movies has become reality! Imagine if all electrical outlets had the ability to monitor and capture your home or office energy use, carbon output data ...